Tuesday, June 22, 2010
How was the trip?- an impossible question
Returning from a trip like this inevitably greets you repeatedly with the question “How was the trip?” This is an impossible question to answer as we observed so much in a short span of time. Though I know I will continue to reflect on these experiences in the coming days, months, and years, I can identify certain trajectories I hope to implement here and now. As globalization continues, our churches will have more and more opportunity for intercultural interaction. Whether it is immigrants entering our country, or mosques being built in our communities, I hope our churches can extend hospitality and welcome in the name of Christ. Also, we must continue to find ways of supporting and being involved with justice endeavors. Our worship should continually point us outward, as we pray for, work with, and incorporate aspects of worship from our international brothers and sisters in Christ.
Christian Witness in Religious Diversity
We had the privilege of visiting a church in each context and spending some time at each with a pastor of the congregation. In Vietnam, we visited a Protestant church whose service quite closely resembled typical Protestant worship in the states. They sang western hymn tunes and spoke the Lord’s Prayer and Apostles’ Creed. They had special music, a lengthy sermon, and the building looked like what we would expect a church to look like. It appeared to be a tame and unordinary church experience. Perhaps we wanted to hear traditional Vietnamese music or see more original expressions of worship. But I do not think we have any idea what constraints they are under.
Maybe we underestimate the fact that by appearing to be a typical Protestant church service recognizable to Westerners, they are inherently countercultural. Just because that experience is the spiritual air we breathe in our churches, the Protestant Christian story is radically different from what the dominant Vietnamese culture is telling. Further, we have no idea what being officially recognized by the government means for that church. I cannot pretend to understand the implications of deciding whether to be recognized or go underground. I am thankful that they are living out their faith in their own way, and I am grateful to have been able to encounter their Christian journey in Vietnam.
Our church experience in Cambodia was quite different. They did not appear to be under constraints like the Vietnamese church. Because of that, the New Life Fellowship church in Cambodia had an impressive array of social programs like health awareness, job training, and child mentorship programs. Their worship service also had recognizable elements, particularly the music. It is a more and more common phenomenon that the global church is singing the same repertoire of songs. Some people lament this but I am not inclined to judge international churches’ decisions about how to structure their worship. The fact that they have translated songs into their own language helps them take ownership of the process.
I was impressed by several things in the Cambodian church. It was a very young church, which is not surprising since it is a very young country. But they are shaping the lives of young people in light of the message of the gospel. Also, in addition to their outreach work, they are very proactive in evangelism. When our group asked about the difficulty of evangelism in their context, one pastor replied that evangelism was actually quite easy. I did not interpret this as a simplification of what evangelism entails, but rather a testament to the fact that young people in Cambodia are hungry for God. This church seems to be meeting that need in a powerful way.
Both countries are incredibly religious. There are pagodas, temples, and churches everywhere. However, the churches in Vietnam are under much more of a constraint than churches in Cambodia. Both are seeking to incarnate the gospel in whatever way they can. They have inherited the Christian tradition by various means and by equally diverse means are translating that into their own expressions of worship. It is exciting to see local churches initiate so many ministries in their context. I think we have a great deal to learn from them as many of our own denominations are in decline. Going forward, I hope that we in the West will be willing to listen.
Maybe we underestimate the fact that by appearing to be a typical Protestant church service recognizable to Westerners, they are inherently countercultural. Just because that experience is the spiritual air we breathe in our churches, the Protestant Christian story is radically different from what the dominant Vietnamese culture is telling. Further, we have no idea what being officially recognized by the government means for that church. I cannot pretend to understand the implications of deciding whether to be recognized or go underground. I am thankful that they are living out their faith in their own way, and I am grateful to have been able to encounter their Christian journey in Vietnam.
Our church experience in Cambodia was quite different. They did not appear to be under constraints like the Vietnamese church. Because of that, the New Life Fellowship church in Cambodia had an impressive array of social programs like health awareness, job training, and child mentorship programs. Their worship service also had recognizable elements, particularly the music. It is a more and more common phenomenon that the global church is singing the same repertoire of songs. Some people lament this but I am not inclined to judge international churches’ decisions about how to structure their worship. The fact that they have translated songs into their own language helps them take ownership of the process.
I was impressed by several things in the Cambodian church. It was a very young church, which is not surprising since it is a very young country. But they are shaping the lives of young people in light of the message of the gospel. Also, in addition to their outreach work, they are very proactive in evangelism. When our group asked about the difficulty of evangelism in their context, one pastor replied that evangelism was actually quite easy. I did not interpret this as a simplification of what evangelism entails, but rather a testament to the fact that young people in Cambodia are hungry for God. This church seems to be meeting that need in a powerful way.
Both countries are incredibly religious. There are pagodas, temples, and churches everywhere. However, the churches in Vietnam are under much more of a constraint than churches in Cambodia. Both are seeking to incarnate the gospel in whatever way they can. They have inherited the Christian tradition by various means and by equally diverse means are translating that into their own expressions of worship. It is exciting to see local churches initiate so many ministries in their context. I think we have a great deal to learn from them as many of our own denominations are in decline. Going forward, I hope that we in the West will be willing to listen.
Thin Places
The theological counterparts to dark places are thin places. These are the places where heaven and earth meet. It is where there is just enough hope to permeate the darkness and overcome it. They may or may not be grandiose, often they are small and not readily noticeable, but they are very real. Thankfully, we experienced several of these types of places as well.
The first of these was our time at An Giang University in Long Xuyen, Vietnam. It was refreshing to have extended interaction with the people in the culture. Further, I’ve always enjoyed interacting with students from other cultures because they are usually equally eager to engage in conversation. Our time with them was short but very meaningful and it culminated in our intercultural talent show. It was one of those events that seemed really important to our hosts, though we were never entirely sure of what was expected of us. Nevertheless, we put together a few acts including two classic youth group skits, a guitar piece that I played, and a gospel song that we all sang.
The whole evening was filled with excitement as both groups sought to present the best of their cultures. As I reflect on the experience after the fact, it felt like we were representing much more than merely ourselves. They obviously knew we were Americans, but they also knew we were Christians. Though we did not have the opportunity to publicly proclaim the gospel, we were able to do so through our song. By no means were all of us singers, but that one moment was perhaps the most direct way we were able to share the gospel. So we poured our hearts into it to an audience that included Buddhists, Hindus, some Christians, and a communist party member. We were representing our school for sure. We also represented our country. But on all of our minds was how we were representing the joy that we have found in Christ. I hope and pray that came across in our actions.
In Cambodia, we desperately needed to experience a thin place after our visits to the S-21 prison and killing fields. The thing about thin places is that they are often unexpected, and so it was this night. Our travel guide while in Cambodia, Maria, invited us into her parents’ home after visiting her community’s mosque. Her family is part of a Muslim ethnic minority in Cambodia who suffered mightily during the Khmer Rouge regime. We very quickly crossed the line from tourists to pilgrims as we entered their home and sat in their living room. I am so grateful that she felt comfortable enough with our group to invite us into their sacred space. As we sat there, her parents shared stories about that time period and how they survived, but how many of their family members did not. As they spoke, I was amazed at the obvious love shared between all of them. Here was a family that is thriving and choosing to embrace life in defiance of those that wanted to rob them of it. It was truly a privilege to be welcomed into their home.
The following day we visited two incredible organizations doing some amazing work in Cambodia. We first met with Hagar International and heard about their work with victims of sexual abuse, particularly those in human trafficking. Their dedication and care for each individual was inspiring. They shared many stories of individuals in their programs whose lives have been turned around. We then met with a local office of the International Justice Mission, whose work is similar but focused more on justice systems than the individuals within the systems. They train local police forces, judges, and provide legal recourse to those who would not have any otherwise. It is difficult work, but their passion born out of the call they have received from encountering the way of Jesus keeps them going. What also impressed me was both organizations’ commitment to prayer. They intentionally spend time together each day in prayer. It is not just a nice phrase tacked on to a mission statement but it is a discipline they practice regularly.
On our last day in Cambodia, we visited a fair trade shop called Rehab Craft Cambodia. On the upper level was a typical craft store with bags, jewelry, and wooden crafts. Underneath the shop were various workshops where all of the products were made. We were able to walk through the workshops, which enabled the mission of the shop to come to life. They are a fair trade shop “run by and for Cambodians with disabilities that provides support and creates job opportunities by producing quality handcrafts” (Rehab Craft website). This was another experience that took us from being tourists to pilgrims. We viewed a part of their journey from being marginalized to having a sustainable way of life. I was proud of our group that day, as we supported them immensely instead of holding out for the cheaper market prices.
These thin places did not erase the memory of the dark places. But they did remind us that darkness does not have the last word. All of these organizations are creatively confronting the narratives of darkness with new stories of life and hope. I am tremendously grateful for these memories as we prepared to return home.
The first of these was our time at An Giang University in Long Xuyen, Vietnam. It was refreshing to have extended interaction with the people in the culture. Further, I’ve always enjoyed interacting with students from other cultures because they are usually equally eager to engage in conversation. Our time with them was short but very meaningful and it culminated in our intercultural talent show. It was one of those events that seemed really important to our hosts, though we were never entirely sure of what was expected of us. Nevertheless, we put together a few acts including two classic youth group skits, a guitar piece that I played, and a gospel song that we all sang.
The whole evening was filled with excitement as both groups sought to present the best of their cultures. As I reflect on the experience after the fact, it felt like we were representing much more than merely ourselves. They obviously knew we were Americans, but they also knew we were Christians. Though we did not have the opportunity to publicly proclaim the gospel, we were able to do so through our song. By no means were all of us singers, but that one moment was perhaps the most direct way we were able to share the gospel. So we poured our hearts into it to an audience that included Buddhists, Hindus, some Christians, and a communist party member. We were representing our school for sure. We also represented our country. But on all of our minds was how we were representing the joy that we have found in Christ. I hope and pray that came across in our actions.
In Cambodia, we desperately needed to experience a thin place after our visits to the S-21 prison and killing fields. The thing about thin places is that they are often unexpected, and so it was this night. Our travel guide while in Cambodia, Maria, invited us into her parents’ home after visiting her community’s mosque. Her family is part of a Muslim ethnic minority in Cambodia who suffered mightily during the Khmer Rouge regime. We very quickly crossed the line from tourists to pilgrims as we entered their home and sat in their living room. I am so grateful that she felt comfortable enough with our group to invite us into their sacred space. As we sat there, her parents shared stories about that time period and how they survived, but how many of their family members did not. As they spoke, I was amazed at the obvious love shared between all of them. Here was a family that is thriving and choosing to embrace life in defiance of those that wanted to rob them of it. It was truly a privilege to be welcomed into their home.
The following day we visited two incredible organizations doing some amazing work in Cambodia. We first met with Hagar International and heard about their work with victims of sexual abuse, particularly those in human trafficking. Their dedication and care for each individual was inspiring. They shared many stories of individuals in their programs whose lives have been turned around. We then met with a local office of the International Justice Mission, whose work is similar but focused more on justice systems than the individuals within the systems. They train local police forces, judges, and provide legal recourse to those who would not have any otherwise. It is difficult work, but their passion born out of the call they have received from encountering the way of Jesus keeps them going. What also impressed me was both organizations’ commitment to prayer. They intentionally spend time together each day in prayer. It is not just a nice phrase tacked on to a mission statement but it is a discipline they practice regularly.
On our last day in Cambodia, we visited a fair trade shop called Rehab Craft Cambodia. On the upper level was a typical craft store with bags, jewelry, and wooden crafts. Underneath the shop were various workshops where all of the products were made. We were able to walk through the workshops, which enabled the mission of the shop to come to life. They are a fair trade shop “run by and for Cambodians with disabilities that provides support and creates job opportunities by producing quality handcrafts” (Rehab Craft website). This was another experience that took us from being tourists to pilgrims. We viewed a part of their journey from being marginalized to having a sustainable way of life. I was proud of our group that day, as we supported them immensely instead of holding out for the cheaper market prices.
These thin places did not erase the memory of the dark places. But they did remind us that darkness does not have the last word. All of these organizations are creatively confronting the narratives of darkness with new stories of life and hope. I am tremendously grateful for these memories as we prepared to return home.
Dark Places
One of the authors we read prior to the trip used the phrase “dark places” to describe those places that seem to be monuments of God’s absence (Forest). They are places where atrocities once occurred, evil was carried out unabatedly, and innocent lives were lost. Our first full day in Cambodia brought us face to face with two such places. With the words of the Documentation Center director still in our ears, we prepared to encounter the S-21 prison followed by a killing field site outside of the city.
The S-21 prison had been built as a multi-building school campus in the 1960’s. However, the Khmer Rouge turned it into one of the most heinous of their “security centers”, where they imprisoned, tortured, interrogated, and executed thousands of men and women. The prison was a short block and a half walk from our hotel and as you turn the corner of the street it is on, the prison looms like a dark cloud in an otherwise clear sky. Technically, it is a museum now but very little has been added in terms of what you would expect in a museum. There are minimal signs, dividers, or roped off sections to separate the viewer from what is being viewed. Because of this, walking through the hallways and rooms of the buildings allowed for a more thorough entry into the suffering of the story being told.
In what were once classrooms, the Khmer Rouge built individual prison cells out of bricks. They put barbed wire fencing down the entire front of the buildings to prevent prisoners from committing suicide. In one particular room, the museum displayed thousands of photographs taken of the prisoners. There was this overwhelming sense, looking at the photographs, that they were looking directly at me, imploring to be heard. After walking through a room with various devices used for torture, I made my way outside past the gallows, where children once did their morning exercises before school. The warning of Thich Nhat Hanh came to mind, that clinging unwaveringly to ideology has killed millions of people throughout history. The Khmer Rouge had a vision for the history of Cambodia and held so tightly to that vision that they were willing to kill whoever did not fit into the plan.
After visiting the prison we visited one of many killing fields sites in Cambodia. This particular one was just a few miles outside of Phnom Penh and likely where prisoners of S-21 were transported. Much like the S-21 museum, the place was very raw, as if the Khmer Rouge had only recently left. In fact, they still have not excavated all of the graves. Our guide told us that when it rains, fragments of clothing or even bone can be seen on the ground surface. Sure enough, within minutes it began pouring and we all sought shelter beneath the canopy of the monument to those who died there. Because of the wind and direction of the rain, we were all facing the center of the monument, which displayed on multiple levels the clothing and bones of the bodies that were exhumed in that place.
After the rain let up we began our walk on the path that ran through the killing fields. I will never forget the sight of the hundreds of ditches that were once mass graves. I will never forget the sight of a tree against which the Khmer Rouge killed infants and small children. I will never forget the sight of clothing and bone fragments still in the ground. In our reading, we came across the practice of preserving relics within the church. For Protestants, this normally seems like a strange and far too superstitious practice. I am not so sure anymore. You can read all you want about the lives of the saints or even a tragedy like the Khmer Rouge genocides. But actually being physically present does something internally like nothing else can.
Our exposure to both of these sites helped put in perspective the words of the DC Cambodia director. We were overwhelmed by the tragedy and so could understand resorting to despair and the unwillingness to forgive. It is hard to describe the scope of these events and their effect on subsequent Cambodian history. It is estimated that around 2 million people died out of a population of around 7 million. Today, half of the population of Cambodia is under the age of 22. Essentially, the nation had to start from scratch and rebuild the culture. There are entire generations of families gone, and younger generations emerging who are eager to take ownership of the days ahead.
The S-21 prison had been built as a multi-building school campus in the 1960’s. However, the Khmer Rouge turned it into one of the most heinous of their “security centers”, where they imprisoned, tortured, interrogated, and executed thousands of men and women. The prison was a short block and a half walk from our hotel and as you turn the corner of the street it is on, the prison looms like a dark cloud in an otherwise clear sky. Technically, it is a museum now but very little has been added in terms of what you would expect in a museum. There are minimal signs, dividers, or roped off sections to separate the viewer from what is being viewed. Because of this, walking through the hallways and rooms of the buildings allowed for a more thorough entry into the suffering of the story being told.
In what were once classrooms, the Khmer Rouge built individual prison cells out of bricks. They put barbed wire fencing down the entire front of the buildings to prevent prisoners from committing suicide. In one particular room, the museum displayed thousands of photographs taken of the prisoners. There was this overwhelming sense, looking at the photographs, that they were looking directly at me, imploring to be heard. After walking through a room with various devices used for torture, I made my way outside past the gallows, where children once did their morning exercises before school. The warning of Thich Nhat Hanh came to mind, that clinging unwaveringly to ideology has killed millions of people throughout history. The Khmer Rouge had a vision for the history of Cambodia and held so tightly to that vision that they were willing to kill whoever did not fit into the plan.
After visiting the prison we visited one of many killing fields sites in Cambodia. This particular one was just a few miles outside of Phnom Penh and likely where prisoners of S-21 were transported. Much like the S-21 museum, the place was very raw, as if the Khmer Rouge had only recently left. In fact, they still have not excavated all of the graves. Our guide told us that when it rains, fragments of clothing or even bone can be seen on the ground surface. Sure enough, within minutes it began pouring and we all sought shelter beneath the canopy of the monument to those who died there. Because of the wind and direction of the rain, we were all facing the center of the monument, which displayed on multiple levels the clothing and bones of the bodies that were exhumed in that place.
After the rain let up we began our walk on the path that ran through the killing fields. I will never forget the sight of the hundreds of ditches that were once mass graves. I will never forget the sight of a tree against which the Khmer Rouge killed infants and small children. I will never forget the sight of clothing and bone fragments still in the ground. In our reading, we came across the practice of preserving relics within the church. For Protestants, this normally seems like a strange and far too superstitious practice. I am not so sure anymore. You can read all you want about the lives of the saints or even a tragedy like the Khmer Rouge genocides. But actually being physically present does something internally like nothing else can.
Our exposure to both of these sites helped put in perspective the words of the DC Cambodia director. We were overwhelmed by the tragedy and so could understand resorting to despair and the unwillingness to forgive. It is hard to describe the scope of these events and their effect on subsequent Cambodian history. It is estimated that around 2 million people died out of a population of around 7 million. Today, half of the population of Cambodia is under the age of 22. Essentially, the nation had to start from scratch and rebuild the culture. There are entire generations of families gone, and younger generations emerging who are eager to take ownership of the days ahead.
Monday, June 21, 2010
Listening to the Other
I was not thrilled at the news that Vietnam was the destination of our senior trip. This reaction was not based on any legitimate experience of my own, but rather what seems to be an absorbed cultural posture based on the history of our two nations. As someone who did not live through that time period, my only reference point for Vietnam was the accumulation of what I learned in school as well as what I saw in movies. The result of this was perhaps some level of intimidation. It did not help when people would ask me why on earth I would want to go to Vietnam. It was helpful to discover people who could offer a counterbalance to that perception. Several people encouraged me, based on their own experience, about the beauty of the country and the hospitality and friendliness of the people. By the time we arrived in Saigon, I was ready to experience the culture for myself.
I found Saigon to be a very comfortable place to explore. All of the activity of the city continued around us. I expected us to stick out more, or at least attract more attention. However, it really did not seem out of the ordinary that a group of North American students would be walking around the streets of Saigon. Our first scheduled item on our itinerary was a visit to the War Remnants museum. This is the Vietnamese telling of the history of the war. This was a difficult experience to say the least. It was as if our brains were trying to take in new information that conflicted with already existing information. In the story the museum was telling, the Americans were clearly the antagonists.
Now, I do not pretend to understand all of the political events that led to the Vietnam War. Even after this trip I am amazed at how interrelated certain events were during those turbulent years. At the least, what this experience yielded was the opportunity to listen to the other side of the story. Through the photographs, captions, and narratives, I was exposed to parts of the story I have never heard before. I was horrified to read about the effects of Agent Orange that linger even today, causing numerous birth defects and complications. I lamented the stories of countless villagers who lost homes and family members in the conflict. In the back of my mind was the knowledge that this is a country that throughout its history has almost always had a foreign power vying for rule. I left the museum with very ambiguous feelings. On one hand, I realized that no museum can tell the whole truth since it comes from a particular perspective. The phrase that history is written by the victors comes to mind. On the other hand, it occurred to me that at least being willing to listen to the voice of the other, particularly when it is the voice of former enemies, is a crucial step towards forgiveness and reconciliation. Further, the context of forgiveness and reconciliation seems like the only way for the whole truth to be told.
We had a similar though unexpected experience at dinner later that evening. We had been told that the place where we were eating dinner was a notable historic site. We discovered that several floors above the restaurant there was a secret meeting room that was used during the war by the Viet Cong. It was during meetings in this location that the Tet Offensive was planned. It was a bit unsettling because despite the historical significance, there was still the reality that thousands of casualties on both sides of the conflict resulted from plans made in a room where we were then standing. Listening to the other is not always easy or comfortable. It is often the opposite. But I do believe and maintain that it is necessary for any hope of forgiveness and reconciliation. As Christians, we need to be willing to occupy those ambiguous spaces.
I found Saigon to be a very comfortable place to explore. All of the activity of the city continued around us. I expected us to stick out more, or at least attract more attention. However, it really did not seem out of the ordinary that a group of North American students would be walking around the streets of Saigon. Our first scheduled item on our itinerary was a visit to the War Remnants museum. This is the Vietnamese telling of the history of the war. This was a difficult experience to say the least. It was as if our brains were trying to take in new information that conflicted with already existing information. In the story the museum was telling, the Americans were clearly the antagonists.
Now, I do not pretend to understand all of the political events that led to the Vietnam War. Even after this trip I am amazed at how interrelated certain events were during those turbulent years. At the least, what this experience yielded was the opportunity to listen to the other side of the story. Through the photographs, captions, and narratives, I was exposed to parts of the story I have never heard before. I was horrified to read about the effects of Agent Orange that linger even today, causing numerous birth defects and complications. I lamented the stories of countless villagers who lost homes and family members in the conflict. In the back of my mind was the knowledge that this is a country that throughout its history has almost always had a foreign power vying for rule. I left the museum with very ambiguous feelings. On one hand, I realized that no museum can tell the whole truth since it comes from a particular perspective. The phrase that history is written by the victors comes to mind. On the other hand, it occurred to me that at least being willing to listen to the voice of the other, particularly when it is the voice of former enemies, is a crucial step towards forgiveness and reconciliation. Further, the context of forgiveness and reconciliation seems like the only way for the whole truth to be told.
We had a similar though unexpected experience at dinner later that evening. We had been told that the place where we were eating dinner was a notable historic site. We discovered that several floors above the restaurant there was a secret meeting room that was used during the war by the Viet Cong. It was during meetings in this location that the Tet Offensive was planned. It was a bit unsettling because despite the historical significance, there was still the reality that thousands of casualties on both sides of the conflict resulted from plans made in a room where we were then standing. Listening to the other is not always easy or comfortable. It is often the opposite. But I do believe and maintain that it is necessary for any hope of forgiveness and reconciliation. As Christians, we need to be willing to occupy those ambiguous spaces.
Further reflections
As a final assignment for this course, we are writing an integrative paper that tries to connect all the pieces together (our trip experience + readings + conversations...). I will post it here in segments...Here's the intro..
“Prosecution is forgiveness.” These words, spoken to our group on a tremendously hot day in Phnom Penh, broke through our collective lethargy and alerted us to the fact that a significant exchange was taking place. We were speaking with the director of the Documentation Center of Cambodia, an organization that has been gathering information about Democratic Kampuchea and their horrific four-year regime in order to serve memory and justice on behalf of the people of Cambodia. It was a chance encounter, as our tour of the facility happened to come to a stop outside of the office he was occupying. He spoke from personal experience about that tragic time period and how it has affected subsequent generations. He also expressed his personal inability to forgive those responsible, as well as a more implicit disillusionment with religion. Apparently, not even God could intervene to stop the killing.
I suspect that for many of us, this brief encounter was a defining moment of our trip to Vietnam and Cambodia. Everything quickly shifted from the general to the particular, from the abstract to the immensely personal. Everything that had occurred prior to that moment, as well as everything that came later, now seemed much more real and tangible. It encapsulated many of the themes that kept emerging throughout our many experiences and conversations. As I reflect on this trip, I will integrate my thoughts into these broad themes. The first is the notion of listening to the voice of the “other.” Then, I will reflect on what we have called thin and dark places. Lastly, I will reflect upon our exposure to the churches in both contexts, especially as to how it relates to Christian witness in a context of diverse religious expression.
“Prosecution is forgiveness.” These words, spoken to our group on a tremendously hot day in Phnom Penh, broke through our collective lethargy and alerted us to the fact that a significant exchange was taking place. We were speaking with the director of the Documentation Center of Cambodia, an organization that has been gathering information about Democratic Kampuchea and their horrific four-year regime in order to serve memory and justice on behalf of the people of Cambodia. It was a chance encounter, as our tour of the facility happened to come to a stop outside of the office he was occupying. He spoke from personal experience about that tragic time period and how it has affected subsequent generations. He also expressed his personal inability to forgive those responsible, as well as a more implicit disillusionment with religion. Apparently, not even God could intervene to stop the killing.
I suspect that for many of us, this brief encounter was a defining moment of our trip to Vietnam and Cambodia. Everything quickly shifted from the general to the particular, from the abstract to the immensely personal. Everything that had occurred prior to that moment, as well as everything that came later, now seemed much more real and tangible. It encapsulated many of the themes that kept emerging throughout our many experiences and conversations. As I reflect on this trip, I will integrate my thoughts into these broad themes. The first is the notion of listening to the voice of the “other.” Then, I will reflect on what we have called thin and dark places. Lastly, I will reflect upon our exposure to the churches in both contexts, especially as to how it relates to Christian witness in a context of diverse religious expression.
Monday, June 14, 2010
Home Sweet Home
It has been great to be home! I'm surprised how easily it has been to adjust back to the time zone here, but my thought is that the flights were disorienting enough that any sense of normalcy aids the adjustment process. I arrived home around 3pm on Saturday. After talking about the trip a bit with Rachel, I literally could not keep my eyes open. I didn't want to nap b/c I wanted to go to bed at a normal hour here, but I had no choice. I had to sleep for a couple hours.
Rachel woke me up at 7 for dinner-I had requested hamburgers as my first meal back and they were delicious. The nap was helpful but it felt like coming out of a coma and all I wanted to do was go back to sleep. Rachel forced me to stay up to 8:30, at which point I eagerly went to sleep for about 10 hours. There are few things as sacred as one's own bed.
There's still a lot going on in my head concerning this trip so I will continue updating this blog as the thoughts are ready for dispersal. Plus, it is way easier to type on a computer than it is on an iphone, which I was using on the trip.
Rachel woke me up at 7 for dinner-I had requested hamburgers as my first meal back and they were delicious. The nap was helpful but it felt like coming out of a coma and all I wanted to do was go back to sleep. Rachel forced me to stay up to 8:30, at which point I eagerly went to sleep for about 10 hours. There are few things as sacred as one's own bed.
There's still a lot going on in my head concerning this trip so I will continue updating this blog as the thoughts are ready for dispersal. Plus, it is way easier to type on a computer than it is on an iphone, which I was using on the trip.
Friday, June 11, 2010
Random other things
I thought I would reflect on some of the more mundane things from the trip.
1. Many of the bathrooms were interesting in the hotels we stayed in. There was no real separation between the toilet, sink, and shower. They all shared the same small space so that when you showered, you basically got everything wet (toilet, sink, walls, etc.) I wonder if they've considered taking it a step further and removing the toilet and putting in a bigger drain. It all goes to the same place right?
2. Doing laundry at our last hotel was fairly adventurous. It was a free service and probably for good reason. You were supposed to leave clothes in a basket outside the door. Then the laundry fairy would take them away. It didn't happen to me, but many people recieved an assortment of clean clothes back, some their's and some not. So it just took some time to sort it all out.
3. There some humorous misprints in some of the literature in our hotels. Each hotel had a list of hotel rules translated into English. The translator did an admirable job, though left us some memorable moments. For example, it was not permitted to have "prostitubes" in one hotel. In another we were not permitted to have "pegs", which we think is supposed to mean "pets". And lastly, some mysterious thing called "the drog" is not permitted in another hotel. My best guess for this is that drugs are illegal there.
4. I don't need to eat rice for a very long time.
1. Many of the bathrooms were interesting in the hotels we stayed in. There was no real separation between the toilet, sink, and shower. They all shared the same small space so that when you showered, you basically got everything wet (toilet, sink, walls, etc.) I wonder if they've considered taking it a step further and removing the toilet and putting in a bigger drain. It all goes to the same place right?
2. Doing laundry at our last hotel was fairly adventurous. It was a free service and probably for good reason. You were supposed to leave clothes in a basket outside the door. Then the laundry fairy would take them away. It didn't happen to me, but many people recieved an assortment of clean clothes back, some their's and some not. So it just took some time to sort it all out.
3. There some humorous misprints in some of the literature in our hotels. Each hotel had a list of hotel rules translated into English. The translator did an admirable job, though left us some memorable moments. For example, it was not permitted to have "prostitubes" in one hotel. In another we were not permitted to have "pegs", which we think is supposed to mean "pets". And lastly, some mysterious thing called "the drog" is not permitted in another hotel. My best guess for this is that drugs are illegal there.
4. I don't need to eat rice for a very long time.
Thin Places Part 2
On Thursday we continued visiting with organizations working toward change in small but significant ways.
First, we visited Rehab Craft, a local fair trade organization run by and for Cambodian people with disabilities. Much of their stuff often is sold in 10000 Villages. The store was pretty unassuming, but the co-director took us on a tour of the facility. We saw workers sewing, carving wood, working with silver, and doing all of this with huge smiles and gracious spirits. Our whole cohort bought a lot of stuff from them, which brought the whole experience together. We bought stuff that was literally made below the store.
We then visited with folks from the Mennonite Central Committee. They partner with local Cambodian organizations who are effecting positive change in the country.
It was a nice series of encounters that left us with real glimpses of hope in a country that has endured so much.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
First, we visited Rehab Craft, a local fair trade organization run by and for Cambodian people with disabilities. Much of their stuff often is sold in 10000 Villages. The store was pretty unassuming, but the co-director took us on a tour of the facility. We saw workers sewing, carving wood, working with silver, and doing all of this with huge smiles and gracious spirits. Our whole cohort bought a lot of stuff from them, which brought the whole experience together. We bought stuff that was literally made below the store.
We then visited with folks from the Mennonite Central Committee. They partner with local Cambodian organizations who are effecting positive change in the country.
It was a nice series of encounters that left us with real glimpses of hope in a country that has endured so much.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Thursday, June 10, 2010
Thin Places
Thin places, on the other hand, are places where heaven and earth meet. Places where hope breaks through the darkest night. I'm thankful our schedule was arranged for us to meet with 2 outstanding organizations after a difficult and emotional day.
We met with Hagar International, who works to rehabilitate and reintegrate victims of sexual abuse. Human trafficking is a big issue in Cambodia and they do some amazing work. They are a Christian organization and it was so encouraging to see and hear the staff members' passion for what they are doing.
We then met with International Justice Mission, who are more on the front end of anti-trafficking. Also a Christian organization, they collaborate with local justice systems to rescue victims from abusive situations as well as provide access to legal recourse.
Both show how Christians can incarnate the gospel in dramatically powerful ways to impact social systems. This was an inspiring day.
At night we spent time in conversation and worship with a large Pentecostal church. They have planted 32 churches throughout the country and seem to have a vibrant worship and cell group ministry.
They also have very impressive outreach ministries in the community. It was refreshing to be in worship with about 100 young people. Bc of the KR regime, half of the current population is under 22. So the younger generations have immense potential for shaping the future of Cambodia.
They had translation readily available for songs and message so it was easier to follow. We also recognized some of the songs so we could engage way more than in Vietnam.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
We met with Hagar International, who works to rehabilitate and reintegrate victims of sexual abuse. Human trafficking is a big issue in Cambodia and they do some amazing work. They are a Christian organization and it was so encouraging to see and hear the staff members' passion for what they are doing.
We then met with International Justice Mission, who are more on the front end of anti-trafficking. Also a Christian organization, they collaborate with local justice systems to rescue victims from abusive situations as well as provide access to legal recourse.
Both show how Christians can incarnate the gospel in dramatically powerful ways to impact social systems. This was an inspiring day.
At night we spent time in conversation and worship with a large Pentecostal church. They have planted 32 churches throughout the country and seem to have a vibrant worship and cell group ministry.
They also have very impressive outreach ministries in the community. It was refreshing to be in worship with about 100 young people. Bc of the KR regime, half of the current population is under 22. So the younger generations have immense potential for shaping the future of Cambodia.
They had translation readily available for songs and message so it was easier to follow. We also recognized some of the songs so we could engage way more than in Vietnam.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Dark places
Dark places is a term from one of our books that describes those places that seem empty of all beauty and hope; places where God seems to be absent. We visited 2 such places on Tuesday. If you are not familiar with the Khmer Rouge regime during 1975-1979 I'd suggest googling it. Also the movie "The Killing Fields" is about that time period.
The first place we visited was the S-21 prison museum. Originally intented to be a school campus, the regime used it as a place to imprison, question, torture, and kill anyone they deemed as a threat to the party.
The second place we visited was one of many killing fields sites, where they disposed of over 20,000 bodies in their attempt to purge Cambodia.
The scope of this tragedy is unfathomable. It's estimated that around 2 million Cambodians died under the regime, whether through murder, starvation, or disease. The population was about 7 million at the time so there are whole generations gone forever. There is no one unaffected. Our tour guide, who is 31, lost an older sister and several aunts and uncles.
What was particularly harrowing is that neither site has really had time to "museum-ify". By that I mean there aren't many signs, ropes, or added structures. It is largely as the Khmer Rouge left it. It is almost like they had just left the scene. It is unlike a place such as the Holocaust museum in that they were the actual sites the events occurred. Further, our guide said that when it rains things like clothing fragments and bone fragments can be partially unearthed. Sure enough it poured while were there and you could see both.
It was a pretty overwhelming day, being confronted with immense evil.
These are mass graves that have been excavated.

This is a monument honoring the dead. Inside are the bones and clothing of around 8000 of the victims.

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
The first place we visited was the S-21 prison museum. Originally intented to be a school campus, the regime used it as a place to imprison, question, torture, and kill anyone they deemed as a threat to the party.
The second place we visited was one of many killing fields sites, where they disposed of over 20,000 bodies in their attempt to purge Cambodia.
The scope of this tragedy is unfathomable. It's estimated that around 2 million Cambodians died under the regime, whether through murder, starvation, or disease. The population was about 7 million at the time so there are whole generations gone forever. There is no one unaffected. Our tour guide, who is 31, lost an older sister and several aunts and uncles.
What was particularly harrowing is that neither site has really had time to "museum-ify". By that I mean there aren't many signs, ropes, or added structures. It is largely as the Khmer Rouge left it. It is almost like they had just left the scene. It is unlike a place such as the Holocaust museum in that they were the actual sites the events occurred. Further, our guide said that when it rains things like clothing fragments and bone fragments can be partially unearthed. Sure enough it poured while were there and you could see both.
It was a pretty overwhelming day, being confronted with immense evil.
These are mass graves that have been excavated.
This is a monument honoring the dead. Inside are the bones and clothing of around 8000 of the victims.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Monday, June 7, 2010
Church, Chau Doc, and Cambodia
On Sunday we went to a Protestant church in town that's been around since 1919. It was very interesting. Obviously we understood nothing but could at least recognize other elements.
For example, they sang a few hymns, nearly all of which were familiar (like Come Thou Fount). Imagine you were transported to a CMA church in the 70's but everything was in Vietnamese. That was essentially what it was like. That and extremely hot. I could feel the beads of sweat run down my stomach and I sat by the one fan that didn't work.
I also recognized the apostles' creed and lord's prayer by the phrasing. It was also communion Sunday, which was very meaningful. Im not sure people knew what to make of us being there.
After church we met with the pastor so he could tell us about the church as well as what the situation is for churches in Vietnam.
After lunch on campus we drove 2 hours to Chau Doc, a city on the Mekong delta. All we had time for was to walk around the city, have dinner and dessert, and call it a night.
This morning we took a 5 hour boat ride into Cambodia. We met up with our guide and had a great lunch. Side note: the food on this trip has been fantastic and way cheap. Those who know me know how much I love the combo of good and cheap food.
After lunch we went to the DC Cam, where they collect information and documentation about the genocide that took place under the Khmer Rouge. They gave us a tour of their facility. Their mission is to serve memory and justice. We'll be visiting some sites from that tragedy tomorrow.
I'm exhausted but wanted to update the last couple days. Good night!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
For example, they sang a few hymns, nearly all of which were familiar (like Come Thou Fount). Imagine you were transported to a CMA church in the 70's but everything was in Vietnamese. That was essentially what it was like. That and extremely hot. I could feel the beads of sweat run down my stomach and I sat by the one fan that didn't work.
I also recognized the apostles' creed and lord's prayer by the phrasing. It was also communion Sunday, which was very meaningful. Im not sure people knew what to make of us being there.
After church we met with the pastor so he could tell us about the church as well as what the situation is for churches in Vietnam.
After lunch on campus we drove 2 hours to Chau Doc, a city on the Mekong delta. All we had time for was to walk around the city, have dinner and dessert, and call it a night.
This morning we took a 5 hour boat ride into Cambodia. We met up with our guide and had a great lunch. Side note: the food on this trip has been fantastic and way cheap. Those who know me know how much I love the combo of good and cheap food.
After lunch we went to the DC Cam, where they collect information and documentation about the genocide that took place under the Khmer Rouge. They gave us a tour of their facility. Their mission is to serve memory and justice. We'll be visiting some sites from that tragedy tomorrow.
I'm exhausted but wanted to update the last couple days. Good night!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Saturday, June 5, 2010
Last night at An Giang University
The focal point of today was the evening's intercultural talent show. I already mentioned what we prepared but I wanted to highlight what the students prepared.
There were a few traditional Vietnamese songs which were very cool bc the vocal technique and tonality are very different from our western music. There were also a couple more popular sounding Vietnamese songs. One group did a skit telling about this particular region of the country, props and all.
I should mention that they did a lot of this in English. The particular students we've interacted with are all language majors, so they are eager to practice their English.
Back to the acts. One student played guitar and sang " wonderful tonight" by Eric Clapton. They also taught us a game that would take too long to explain here.
All in all it was a very fun evening and these students are very engaging and fun to be with. We will leave here tomorrow after attending the Protestant church.
Oh and our talent acts went very well. Perhaps more on that later.

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
There were a few traditional Vietnamese songs which were very cool bc the vocal technique and tonality are very different from our western music. There were also a couple more popular sounding Vietnamese songs. One group did a skit telling about this particular region of the country, props and all.
I should mention that they did a lot of this in English. The particular students we've interacted with are all language majors, so they are eager to practice their English.
Back to the acts. One student played guitar and sang " wonderful tonight" by Eric Clapton. They also taught us a game that would take too long to explain here.
All in all it was a very fun evening and these students are very engaging and fun to be with. We will leave here tomorrow after attending the Protestant church.
Oh and our talent acts went very well. Perhaps more on that later.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
An Giang University
After a 4 hour or so bus ride we arrived at An Giang University in Long Xuyen, a much more rural area of Vietnam. The first thing we did was eat dinner with a group of students who have been studying English.
It was great to have more extended interaction with the people, and students are particularly fun to interact with. Tonight we are participating in a talent show, which I guess is the best way to describe it. It's one of those things where we're not really sure what exactly it is but all the students are pretty pumped about it.
So the talent we've mustered is a couple classic youth group skits, a simple 4 part gospel song, and I'm playing a guitar piece called "Sunburst". Should be fun!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
It was great to have more extended interaction with the people, and students are particularly fun to interact with. Tonight we are participating in a talent show, which I guess is the best way to describe it. It's one of those things where we're not really sure what exactly it is but all the students are pretty pumped about it.
So the talent we've mustered is a couple classic youth group skits, a simple 4 part gospel song, and I'm playing a guitar piece called "Sunburst". Should be fun!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Friday, June 4, 2010
Leaving Saigon
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Day 2: Saigon
Today we visited many different religous sites in the city: a mosque, Buddhist temple, Hindu temple, and catholic cathedral. It was a lot to take in but interesting to visit them in the same day.
We also enjoyed some great local food for incredibly low prices. Our lunch cost less than a buck a person. Apparently the place was featured on some cooking show with Anthony bourdin.
Tomorrow we head to Long Xuyen, where we'll be hosted by a university and have a good deal of interaction with the students there. But now...to bed.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
We also enjoyed some great local food for incredibly low prices. Our lunch cost less than a buck a person. Apparently the place was featured on some cooking show with Anthony bourdin.
Tomorrow we head to Long Xuyen, where we'll be hosted by a university and have a good deal of interaction with the students there. But now...to bed.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
Saigon day 1
We made it and are all exhausted. So early to bed but not before a couple outings. We walked to the War Remnants museum, aka museum for the war of American imperialism. Needless to say, this was a sobering presentation of events from a perspective I would never hear otherwise. It was difficult to take in as it was very critical of the US and our methods and policies during the war. If for no other reason I value the experience bc it seems like a good idea to listen to our "enemies", as this is surely related to loving them.
After museum we had dinner at a hole in the wall place with some crazy history. The original owner supported Ho Chi Minh and secret Vietcong meetings were held above the restaurant. Again exposure to the "other".
Tomorrow we are visiting many religous sites in the city. Here's a picture of moped traffic. G'night!

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
After museum we had dinner at a hole in the wall place with some crazy history. The original owner supported Ho Chi Minh and secret Vietcong meetings were held above the restaurant. Again exposure to the "other".
Tomorrow we are visiting many religous sites in the city. Here's a picture of moped traffic. G'night!
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
Almost there
1st place that had wifi so a quick update. 2 long flights down and 1 to go. Singapore airlines was real nice- warm towels for our face, steady flow of food and drink, and tons of movies. Can't wait to sleep in a bed. Miss everyone!
Here's a pic from beginning of trip and one just now. Note the difference.


Here's a pic from beginning of trip and one just now. Note the difference.
All Checked In
Well, I'm all checked in and my bag is on it's on its own. Enjoying a pre-flight meal at airport Irish pub.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Sunday, May 30, 2010
Blog app test
Just testing out this blog app...

- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPhone
Location:Derby St,San Francisco,United States
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)